The fiction of the equal boundaries disappearance and border neutralization in the American city

Mejias Villatoro, Paco and Shafique, Tanzil (2017) The fiction of the equal boundaries disappearance and border neutralization in the American city. sITA (Studii de Istoria si Teoria Architecturii / Studies in History and Theory of Architecture), 5. pp. 159-168. ISSN 2344-6544

MejiasVIllatoro-Shafique-2017-The Fiction of the Equal Boundaries Disappearance and Border Neutralization in the American City.pdf
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.

Download (3MB) | Preview
Official URL:


This paper attempts to explain how the concepts of boundary and border (as explained by Sennett in his article “The Open City” ) have evolved in American cities as a way to superficially project an idea of social, economic and racial equality, masquerading a tacit intention of neutralizing the critical sense of the populace. The disappearance of the boundaries (as in limit between clearly different fields) is tied to the very origin of the American urban life. The Main Street, the urban seed of most of the American cities, was created through a weak organizational system of loose geometries and untied fabrics where the landscape filtered continuously in the urban perspectives. In this way, the city refused intentionally to be recognized as the boundary of Nature. On the other hand, the Jeffersonian Grid took command of the outside giving the opposite idea that any piece of Nature could be trespassed at any moment by the artificiality of the Cartesian geometry. The unrecognized boundaries between Urban and Nature resulted in a phenomenon where both entities are blended in a characterless space: the suburban sprawl. With the population dispersed, the spaces for interaction, the borders, can’t happen without a critical mass able to activate them. In this deterritorialized assemblage, the social activity disappears from the quotidian life and is secluded to very specific buildings, mainly the Mall and the Church. In these spaces, the interaction between people has been neutralized by the organized gathering as part of a scripted ritual with very specific routines. The sacralization of both spaces (either by religious or capitalist doctrines) avoids a free interaction or friction between people as a way to mitigate the neutralization of their critical thinking. This is an invisible way in which the status quo closes itself into a frictionless fake sociality, providing the idea of a fictional equality, and hiding a deeper disenfranchisement and in turn making the city fragile/brittle.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: border, boundary, city, social, church, mall
Subjects: E History America > E151 United States (General)
H Social Sciences > HN Social history and conditions. Social problems. Social reform
J Political Science > JK Political institutions (United States)
N Fine Arts > NA Architecture
Divisions: Faculty of Arts, Business & Applied Social Science > Department of Arts & Humanities
Depositing User: Paco Mejias villatoro
Date Deposited: 23 Jun 2021 14:48
Last Modified: 23 Jun 2021 14:48

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year